The TNR Blue Book
The TNR Blue Book logo

What Would Democrats Look Like Under Van Hollen’s Leadership?

He probably won’t win. But if he did, would it change anything?

Presented by CAP
Van Hollen faces several people who are holding phones and wearing press badges.
Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen speaks to reporters in the U.S Capitol Building on November 16.
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images
Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen speaks to reporters in the U.S Capitol Building on November 16.
Presented by CAP

You’re reading The TNR Blue Book. Get daily scoops, strategy, and developments inside the liberal ideas factory delivered right to your inbox. Sign up for free.

Inside Washington

Yesterday, this newsletter covered the likely vote counts for the Senate majority leader contest between Minority Leader Chuck Schumer and Senator Chris Van Hollen. But if Van Hollen were to pull off a win, would he actually lead differently than Schumer would? With Trump in the White House threatening vetoes, substantive policy differences could be limited to a few core issues.

“I think people right now are overemphasizing ideological differences, perceived ideological differences, between the two of them, which is really just not the role of the Senate party leader,” said Mark Schmitt, the director of the political reform program at the think tank New America. Ultimately, he said, the leader doesn’t determine the ideological tone of the Senate; individual senators do.

Still, Van Hollen and Schumer could diverge on Israel and the war in Iran, Schmitt pointed out. So far, Van Hollen has made his views on the war a centerpiece of his surprisingly public and grassroots campaign for leader. Along with a handful of other senators, Van Hollen wants to use the December 11 government funding deadline to push for a stop to the war in Iran. Schumer hasn’t come out either way on the issue.

Van Hollen has also criticized Schumer’s opposition to the Obama-era Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, or JCPOA, also known as the Iran nuclear deal. “We wouldn’t be in this spot if Trump had not torn up the JCPOA. But we wouldn’t even have a JCPOA if the vote of the current leader had prevailed,” Van Hollen said on Monday.

Van Hollen threw another punch at Schumer on November 12, saying that the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee shouldn’t take money from the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, or AIPAC. Schumer used to chair the DSCC, and as Democratic leader, appoints its chair. Van Hollen also said that as leader, he wouldn’t take sides in open primaries. In 2026, Schumer backed moderates in Florida, Maine, Minnesota, and Michigan who lost their primaries.

“If somebody wants a vote on ending U.S. aid to Israel,” Schmitt theorized, “they’re more likely to get that vote with Van Hollen than with Schumer, who’s going to do all he can to say, ‘Not now, we’ll get that vote later.’”

Jim Kessler, the executive vice president for policy at Third Way and a former Schumer staffer, said that it’s easy for Van Hollen to propose big policy swings from his position in the caucus. But as leader, Kessler said, “you are forced to take actions that might anger your base at home and other democratic constituencies because you’re thinking of the broader picture. And no matter what Van Hollen is saying right now, if by some miracle lightning stroke he’s leader, he would have to succumb to those same impulses or be booted out.”

Schumer reiterated on Tuesday that he has the votes to become leader. But Van Hollen and his backers say that they’re not so sure of that. Schumer is publicly backed by 15 senators to Van Hollen’s five backers. That leaves 35 senators uncommitted. The winner will need 28 senators to back him in a closed-ballot election on December 1.

Ultimately, the choice of leader could be more a question of “vibes” (as Schmitt put it) than substance. Committee leaders may ultimately have more impact on legislation and oversight, and there are few questions there: Senator Sheldon Whitehouse will likely run Judiciary, Senator Richard Blumenthal is likely to lead the Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs (which handles oversight), and Senator Bernie Sanders will be at home on Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions.

“Ideologically and generationally, there’s not that much difference between Schumer and Van Hollen,” Kessler said. But the midterm results suggest that maybe Democrats are looking for a different energy. Van Hollen, who rose into the public eye by flying down to El Salvador to meet illegally deported Kilmar Ábrego García, represents a fighting opposition to Trump that many Democrats have been hungry for.

—Emma Janssen

Outside Washington

Democratic Virginia state Senator Mamie Locke this week argued that the Virginia state Senate should not attempt an investigation or expulsion of state Senator L. Louise Lucas, who recently pleaded not guilty to federal racketeering, drug, and money-laundering charges related to her family-run cannabis business. Locke also accused the Trump administration of targeting “powerful Black women.” Locke was responding to Republican Senator Bryce Reeves, who recently pre-filed a Senate resolution to review the charges. You can read the Virginia Mercury’s full report on this and the underlying charges against Locke (they’re pretty complicated) here.

The Agriculture Department’s November 10 proposal to end what’s known as broad-based categorical eligibility for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP, could remove benefits for 6.3 million people, according to the department’s own projections. The Alabama Political Reporter’s Wesley Walter explains that, among other things, categorical eligibility allows low-income families with some savings to still qualify for benefits. Now, for households that no longer qualify, “it means that those children could lose access to no-cost school meals,” LaTrell Clifford Wood of Arise Hunger tells Walter. The policy switch could also lead to an increased error rate in the state, which, according to the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, would lead to the state bearing increased cost-sharing burdens for the SNAP program going forward.

—Heather Souvaine Horn

The Ideas Factory

Data for Progress earlier this week released survey numbers showing 56 percent of “Democratic-leaning voters” favor replacing current Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer with someone new to lead the new Democratic majority. Only 31 percent say Schumer should continue to lead.

The Revolving Door Project has published a statement arguing that Nvidia’s turmoil shows the need for a stock ownership ban for members of Congress, to prevent conflicts of interest. “Today, as the Senate weighs [the permitting reform bill known as] BAAJA—legislation backed by Nvidia and the broader AI industry—at least 50 members of Congress have traded Nvidia stock since late 2023, including one of the bill’s authors, Senator Sheldon Whitehouse (D-RI),” said Revolving Door Project executive director Jeff Hauser in the statement.

The Groundwork Collaborative and the Century Foundation calculate that “the cost of a traditional Thanksgiving dinner is up 11% over the past year, roughly three times the overall rate of inflation.” Groundwork senior adviser Emily DiVito argues in the press release that Trump’s war on Iran and “reckless tariffs” are to blame, and Century Foundation chief economist Kyle Moore likewise cites “policy choices” contributing to households’ budget struggles.

—Heather Souvaine Horn

In Closing

Political Trivia Question of the Day  

As Trump prepares to meet again with Putin and Xi, a two-part question: Who was the first U.S. president to visit China, and who was the first to visit what we then called the Soviet Union? (Sign up for The TNR Blue Book to find the answer in tomorrow’s newsletter.)

—Michael Tomasky

Here’s Where the Schumer–Van Hollen Race Could Get Really Interesting

A handful of senators who haven’t yet declared their positions in the majority leader race could persuade others to change sides.

Presented by CAP
Chris Van Hollen speaks, while standing at a microphone.
Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen speaks at an event in Denver, on November 13.
Timothy Hurst/MediaNews Group/The Denver Post/Getty Images
Maryland Senator Chris Van Hollen speaks at an event in Denver, on November 13.
Presented by CAP

You’re reading The TNR Blue Book. Get daily scoops, strategy, and developments inside the liberal ideas factory delivered right to your inbox. Sign up for free.

Inside Washington

So where do things stand in the race for Senate majority leader? The Blue Book got a whip count on Monday morning assembled by the Progressive Change Campaign Committee. The group is a major backer of Chris Van Hollen’s challenge to Chuck Schumer, but its list is based on the most recent public statements by every senator who’s spoken on the matter.

So here’s the count. The list shows 15 senators in the “firm Schumer” category, including Sheldon Whitehouse, Catherine Cortez Masto, and Angela Alsobrooks. Tim Kaine is in a “presumed Schumer” category of one. Another 15, including Elizabeth Warren and Chris Murphy, are listed as “publicly uncommitted.” Fourteen are listed under “debate/open.” There are five listed as “won’t vote Schumer” (but who haven’t committed publicly to Van Hollen), and five listed as “firm Van Hollen”: Bernie Sanders, Jeff Merkley, Abdul El-Sayed, Peggy Flanagan, and Van Hollen himself.

Over the weekend, Van Hollen took his campaign for Senate majority leader to the public, speaking at the party’s Denver retreat and posting an ad to social media in his bid to replace Chuck Schumer in party leadership come January. The American people voted “against a politics that is too timid to stand up,” he said in his ad. “We have become a party that too often trims its sails. Too cautious, too rudderless. Too attached to poll-washed, pundit-rinsed, and donor-dried messages.”

Van Hollen is making a stir, no doubt about that. But could he actually win? There are two parts to that question. The first is whether Schumer has the votes. Schumer’s team says that he does, and many sitting Democrats who did not face reelection this year have come out firmly in support. “Under Leader Schumer, Democrats won at least 55 seats,” Wisconsin Senator Tammy Baldwin said in a statement. “He earned his position as Majority Leader next Congress.” Pennsylvania Senator John Fetterman even signaled that he’d leave the Democratic Party if Van Hollen were to be elected, because of their differing views on Israel and the war in Gaza.

Schumer only needs a simple majority of the Democrats who gather to vote on Tuesday, December 1. One anonymous Schumer ally recently told The Hill that he thinks Van Hollen and his supporters are just trying to get concessions on priorities. “Van Hollen doesn’t think he’s going to win,” the source said. “I think he’s trying to get some meat on the bone for the causes that the new members want.”

The second part of the question is whether senators who don’t want Schumer leading them will actually coalesce around Van Hollen as an alternative. The whip count shows that, as of Monday morning, there are a lot more senators with some reservations about Schumer than there are senators who are ready to commit to Van Hollen.

Another key question in inside-baseball proceedings like this is: Who are the straws in the wind—the key people whom other senators might follow? One Van Hollen supporter, speaking on background, said the two Georgia senators, Jon Ossoff and Raphael Warnock, may influence their colleagues. “The new people will take significant cues from what Ossoff and Warnock decide to do,” they said. “Either could run for president, so people are paying more attention to them.”

This source also advised paying special attention to the 11 (or more likely 12, with Mary Peltola on the cusp of victory) incoming senators. “If there’s a united front from the incoming members, then it’s close to game over,” this person said. “It’ll be hard for others to say no.” A completely united front is impossible—Sherrod Brown is a “firm Schumer” on the list. But among the new class, says this person, James Talarico is probably the one to watch most closely. Schumer supported Talarico in the primary after Colin Allred dropped out, and Talarico has said that he wants to hear Schumer’s “vision” for the Senate. On the whip count list, Talarico is in the “debate/open” category.

Three other names on the “debate/open” list caught the Blue Book’s eye: Mark Warner, Michael Bennet, and Chris Coons. They’re Senate veterans and institutionalists. If some combination of that trio comes out against Schumer, this could actually get interesting.

—Monica Potts and Michael Tomasky

Outside Washington

Many had already predicted that this would be a rough winter for anyone whose home depends on heating oil. Now, The Guardian drops some sample numbers—staggering ones—illustrating what the expected percent price spike due to President Donald Trump’s war on Iran and Russia’s war on Ukraine could look like for individual households. For 61-year-old Heidi Unruh of Kittery, Maine, Michael Sainato reports that it will cost more than $1,500 to fill the tank that heats her home—double what it cost last year, Unruh says—and the tank will need to be refilled “every 47 days when the temperatures are low.”

Last week, Politico reported that some Democratic politicians are already tamping down expectations about their ability to lower energy prices. “That’s a legitimate issue, and it’s not going to be solved in one political cycle,” Illinois Representative Sean Casten reportedly said. “We’re going to fight like hell to lower prices. We’ll be successful in some areas and not in others,” Senator Brian Schatz of Hawaii was quoted as saying. “I think everybody needs to give citizens credit for understanding that there are three branches of government. We just took over one of the three.”

Elsewhere:

  • The Texas Tribune profiles Ben Flores, the Democrat who recently won the race for Texas land commissioner, even though he “was outfundraised 47 to 1 and spent the home stretch of the campaign in a hospital bed, recovering from cancer treatment.” Flores, an immigrant and pig farmer, tells the Tribune’s Eleanor Klibanoff that he’s “not naive” about the circumstances of his victory: “People were pissed off, and we just happened to be standing there.”

—Heather Souvaine Horn

The Ideas Factory

On Tuesday at 1 p.m., the Rocky Mountain Institute will hold a webinar on the post-midterm political landscape for energy, exploring how midterm results have changed—or not changed—”the outlook for new energy technologies in specific states and regions, and across the U.S. as a whole.” Also on the agenda: “What can states do to address ongoing concerns around affordability, load growth, and economic growth?” The discussion will feature Brian O’Hanlon, Sarah Ladislaw, Jacob Corvidae, Derrick Flakoll, and John Coequyt.

Also on Tuesday, at noon, New America will host a discussion between Better Life Lab director Brigid Schulte and clinical psychologist Darby Saxbe about the latter’s new book, Dad Brain, which explores how “the experience of caring for others” changes the human brain. The discussion will also feature “key findings from the Lab’s new Men and Caregiving survey,” which looked at the barriers keeping fathers from fully participating in caregiving.

—Heather Souvaine Horn

In Closing

Political Trivia Question of the Day  

If you’ve been wondering if Hakeem Jeffries could be president someday (someone must be), then you should know that the odds are long—only one president in U.S. history had previously served as House speaker. Who? (Sign up for The TNR Blue Book to find the answer in tomorrow’s newsletter.)

—Michael Tomasky

Dems Have a Plan to End the Iran War. It’s Risky, Though.

Ro Khanna and Chris Van Hollen think Democrats should use the government funding deadline as leverage.

Presented by CAP
Senator Chris Van Hollen speaks into microphone.
Senator Chris Van Hollen speaks at an event in St. Paul, Minnesota, on November 9.
Stephen Maturen/Getty Images
Senator Chris Van Hollen speaks at an event in St. Paul, Minnesota, on November 9.
Presented by CAP

You’re reading The TNR Blue Book. Get daily scoops, strategy, and developments inside the liberal ideas factory delivered right to your inbox. Sign up for free.

Inside Washington

Democrats won in November in no small part because of their opposition to the war in Iran. Now they have an opportunity to stop that war even before new members of Congress take office. The catch? It could hurt federal workers and the people who depend on them—and burn a lot of political capital.

Representative Ro Khanna and Senator Chris Van Hollen have suggested using the December 11 government funding deadline to push for an end to the war. In this scenario, Dems would withhold votes from a continuing resolution (CR) to keep the government funded, demanding that Congress attach restrictions to war funding if it wants the CR to pass. That, of course, could lead to a government shutdown, and many lawmakers aren’t eager to go down that path just ahead of the holiday season.

“I understand the impulse,” Representative Becca Balint said about the plan to use the CR as leverage. But, she added, “we want to make sure that we are not continuing to—I want to use the right word here—terrorize our federal workforce. They have been through hell and back again.”

The two Democratic appropriations leaders, Senator Patty Murray and Representative Rosa DeLauro, have remained noncommittal on whether they want the CR to include restrictions on war funding. “We’re looking at all options,” Murray told reporters on Thursday. Meanwhile, DeLauro signaled that she’d like to pass a short-term CR to avoid a shutdown and work on a more substantial funding bill in the new Congress. “I want to make it as short as possible,” she told reporters.

House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries likewise declined to endorse a particular strategy and instead deferred to DeLauro. “I don’t want to get out ahead of Congresswoman DeLauro, but House Democrats have uniformly opposed providing any additional money to Donald Trump’s war machine, to Pete Hegseth’s war machine, over in the Middle East,” he said in a press conference on Thursday.

“I think that we should be looking for every way in which not to have a shutdown,” DeLauro told me when I asked for clarification on her position. “But I understand the view that there shouldn’t be the billions of dollars that are being requested, you know, for Iran, and we need to move to end that war. So we’ll look for the various ways in which that might be accomplished.”

Congress has used a continuing resolution this way before. In 1973, legislators successfully used a funding package to force President Richard Nixon to stop bombing Cambodia. Last week, a group of 40 civil society organizations sent a letter to Congress pushing lawmakers to adopt this CR strategy. “We don’t think we should spend one more minute, spend one more penny, to fund this illegal war,” said Cavan Kharrazian, senior policy adviser at Demand Progress, which was a signatory of the letter.

Democrats could also use the National Defense Authorization Act to restrict the war, either by inserting provisions to stop the flow of funding or by withholding votes. The CR is a stronger bet, Kharrazian explained. “The NDAA is considered must-pass, but continuing government funding has much more leverage to it,” he said.

On Thursday, several lawmakers remained tight-lipped on whether they want to use the CR to restrict war funding. “We’re going to do everything we can to bring this war to an end. It’s illegal, a war of choice, and we’re going to do everything we can to keep the government funded,” said Senator Tammy Baldwin. When I asked if she’d prefer not to attach war funding to the CR, she just repeated the same sentence.

Senator Mazie Hirono seemed open to using the CR as leverage. “I think we should make it very clear that the war needs to end, and whatever vehicle we’re going to use for that, I will support,” she said. At the same time, she said she hoped to avoid a government shutdown.

Progressives in the Senate insist that the plan is to keep the government running and say that they need to take the risk regardless. “When we vote on appropriations, we intend to fund the government and stop funds for this war. It is what the American people demand, and what they deserve,” wrote Senators Chris Van Hollen, Michael Bennet, Tammy Duckworth, and Bernie Sanders in a statement.

Van Hollen’s advocacy for ending the war comes as he is considering a challenge to Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer for the majority leader job next year. “I think this is a really important moment for Democratic leadership,” he told The Washington Sun last week. “Are the Democrats, including the Democratic leadership, going to listen to the verdict of the American people and vote to end this war?”

Even if Democrats could theoretically pass a stopgap CR and return to the funding issue again in January, some think that would be an early capitulation for the party, fresh off their November wins. “We should have that fight now,” Kharrazian said. “We shouldn’t allow the money spigot to continue, for even a month.”

—Emma Janssen

Outside Washington

A story to watch, semi-buried in a Washington Post piece about Dems’ new power in state legislatures and governorships: Texas state Representative Brian Harrison, the outlet notes, “has called for a special session to limit the governor’s executive powers while Republicans still control the legislature.” He tells the Post: “If we don’t limit those, [Hinojosa] may well be able to advance her priorities without passing almost any legislation.”

Harrison is not the only lawmaker thinking along these lines. In Ohio this week, anticipating not just Amy Acton’s first days in office but the loss of a GOP supermajority, Republican state Representative Ron Ferguson introduced a joint resolution to amend the state constitution to require only a simple majority to override a gubernatorial veto. Other proposals on the table, according to the Ohio Capital Journal, include one to “expand the General Assembly’s ability to rescind state Department of Health orders”—which Republican House Speaker Matt Huffman called a “good thought.” None of this is new: GOP legislatures in Wisconsin in 2018 and North Carolina in 2024, for example, moved to curtail gubernatorial power in lame-duck sessions before a Democratic governor was set to take over.

Elsewhere:

  • NBC reporter Sahil Kapur noted on Thursday, following the news of Democrat Scott Colom’s stunning victory in Mississippi, that Republican Senator Cindy Hyde-Smith’s official website continues to feature “a 2023 article about how she single-handedly blocked Colom’s nomination to be a federal judge.” For more on this remarkable race, check out The New York Times’s story from last week about Angela Lewis, whose father, James Chaney, was murdered by Klansmen in Mississippi days after her birth. The article describes how Lewis, a nurse, drove straight after an overnight shift to her polling place in Meridian to vote for the candidate who will now become the state’s first Black senator since Reconstruction.
  • The Guardian’s Sam Wolfson explores the phenomenon of the manosphere turning on Donald Trump. The “gay jokes, casual racism, and rape apologia” remain the same, and many of the key players still want immigrants deported. But now they’ve decided that “MAGA is gay.”

—Heather Souvaine Horn

The Ideas Factory

Paparo about “deterrence in the Pacific,” exploring the complexities of U.S. competition with China in the region. Bruce Jones will offer opening remarks, and Lynn Kuok and Michael E. O’Hanlon will moderate.In case you missed it: The World Resources Institute published a useful analysis this week, as Democrats pivoted to thinking about how to deliver on affordability promises, and global policymakers convened in Antalya, Turkey, for COP31 (the United Nations’ annual climate conference). Can electrification help with the affordability crisis? Yes, it can, WRI’s Clem Perry and Nick Wayth write in their explainer. But in order to harness the potential affordability benefits, governments need to make the switch “affordable up front” for households and businesses, “reduce the financing costs for clean power,” and ensure—among other things—that the cheaper price of producing renewable energy is actually reflected in the price passed on to consumers. While that may sound complicated, consider this striking scenario they outline to show the potential benefits:
Take home heating. Electricity can deliver cheaper warmth even when it costs more per unit than gas. A heat pump moves heat rather than generating it by burning fuel, delivering three to four units of heat for every unit of electricity purchased — an effective efficiency of 300-400%. Even at the lower end of that range, a heat pump uses 70% less purchased energy than a modern gas boiler operating at 90% efficiency. That efficiency advantage means that even if electricity costs three times as much per unit as gas, the energy cost of heating is still 10% lower.

—Heather Souvaine Horn

In Closing

Good Week: Scott Colom

While the Democrats have been celebrating their midterm wave for more than a week, the party’s nominee for Senate in Mississippi had to wait until Wednesday for his victory to be declared. And it’s the most historic of all of them this election season: Colom will be the state’s first Democratic senator since segregationist John C. Stennis left office in 1989, and the state’s first Black senator since Reconstruction.

Bad Week: Jensen Huang

The drip-drip of bad news finally swamped the co-founder and CEO of AI chipmaker Nvidia, who resigned on Thursday after The New York Times reported on a second affair—this one with a subordinate, as opposed to a suspected Chinese spy. That proved too much to withstand, even for the head of the $4 trillion company at the heart of the AI investment boom.

—Ryan Kearney

Political Trivia Question of the Day  

Who was the legendary Senate majority leader in the 1960s and ’70s who shepherded through all the major Great Society legislation, and what state was he from? (Sign up for The TNR Blue Book to find the answer in tomorrow’s newsletter.)

—Michael Tomasky

Did the Ice Under Chuck Schumer Just Get a Bit Thinner?

The New York Democrat is facing two potential challenges to his bid to become the next Senate majority leader.

Presented by CAP
U.S. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer poses for a photo with newly elected Democratic senators.
U.S. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer poses for a photo with newly elected Democratic senators in Washington, D.C., on November 9.
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Images
U.S. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer poses for a photo with newly elected Democratic senators in Washington, D.C., on November 9.
Presented by CAP

You’re reading The TNR Blue Book. Get daily scoops, strategy, and developments inside the liberal ideas factory delivered right to your inbox. Sign up for free.

Inside Washington

Senators were skittish on Tuesday when asked if they would support Senator Chuck Schumer for majority leader. Large sections of the Democratic base say they want Schumer out. But alternative plans are scarce, and most Dems won’t do more than hint at them, even when asked outright.

Two potential challenges appear to be brewing: one from Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland and perhaps one from Elissa Slotkin of Michigan. Van Hollen hasn’t outright announced a bid for the role, but he told reporters on Monday: “I’m in listening mode and haven’t shut the door.” On Tuesday, Slotkin appeared with Senator Bernie Sanders to call for a new approach to leadership. Sanders, an independent who caucuses with Democrats, said he is a “no” on Schumer. Slotkin said she is a “no” until she sees a plan for governance. “Whoever wants to run this caucus should come forward with a plan on how they’re going to govern differently, what they’re going to do in the first 100 days to put money in people’s pockets, and then in particular how they’re going to communicate differently.”

Slotkin on Tuesday denied that she is gunning for the role. “I am not actively seeking this job. I am seeking change,” she told reporters. But when I asked specifically if she would ever consider seeking the role, she didn’t give a clear answer.

A number of the newly elected senators, on their way to their first caucus lunch on Tuesday, avoided supporting Schumer outright. “We’re all very clear about the urgency of this moment. How this translates into leadership conversations, that I’m not totally clear on,” said Peggy Flanagan, the senator-elect from Minnesota.

Flanagan beat Schumer-backed Representative Angie Craig in Minnesota’s Democratic primary. Craig wasn’t the only Schumer pick that ultimately lost their race. He also backed Alex Vindman in Florida, who lost to Angie Nixon, and supported Maine Governor Janet Mills, who dropped out of her race. Most disastrous of all was his support for Representative Haley Stevens, who lost her primary to Abdul El-Sayed and underwent a public, multiday crashout before ultimately endorsing the Republican candidate just three days before the general election. Schumer has based much of his argument for reelection on Democrats’ monumental pickups on Tuesday, despite those four airballs.

Van Hollen addressed that issue on Tuesday: “We have two members in that room, newly elected senators, who would not be there if Schumer and the DSCC had had their way,” he told Ali Vitali of MS Now. “Schumer and the DSCC sided with the crypto industry and AIPAC against these candidates.” Others have criticized Schumer for his lack of support for other candidates, like Nixon in Florida and Jamie Davis in Louisiana.

Flanagan didn’t comment specifically on Schumer’s unsuccessful Senate picks, but she did hint at support for Van Hollen. “I really respect Chris Van Hollen, and I’m a big fan of his leadership. And so, we’ll see who decided to step in. But I think Chris Van Hollen is fantastic,” she said.

El-Sayed threw his support behind Van Hollen early on and reiterated it to me today. “It’s an evolving conversation, and I’ve been very clear. I think Senator Van Hollen would be a phenomenal leader.” I asked if he’s been hearing more support for Van Hollen from other members. “A lot of excitement there,” he said.

Even though Schumer is projecting confidence, Murshed Zaheed, a former senior leadership aide to former Majority Leader Harry Reid, noted that he can’t recall a situation like this one, where more than double-digit members of the incoming caucus have shown an eagerness to defect from their Senate leader. He attributes senators’ enthusiasm for Van Hollen in part to Van Hollen’s leadership during some of the darkest days of the second Trump administration.

“The first visible opposition to Trump was Chris Van Hollen’s trip to El Salvador” in April 2025 to meet with Kilmar Abrego Garcia, who the Trump administration deported in violation of court orders. “Until then, the Democrats were completely cowered in their offices in D.C.,” Zaheed said.

When I asked them about leadership, some senators were coy—and didn’t explicitly say they’d support Schumer. “I’m just excited for our first caucus lunch and [to] hear from folks and understand what our options are going to be,” said newly-elected Annie Andrews. Senator Alex Padilla of California merely said that he is “looking forward to our conversation today at lunch.”

—Emma Janssen

Outside Washington

The first place where Democrats’ new power in state governments may be felt? Medicaid. A few stories to watch: In Iowa, Democratic Governor-elect Rob Sand has put reversing the 2016 decision to privatize the state Medicaid program at the top of his agenda. Then there’s Medicaid expansion—an option under the Affordable Care Act that allows state Medicaid programs to cover people earning up to 138 percent of the federal poverty level. In Georgia, Keisha Lance-Bottoms winning the gubernatorial race and Dems winning a narrow majority in the state House has put full expansion on the table (Georgia implemented a partial expansion in 2023). Stateline’s Anna Claire Vollers noted last week that the same could happen in Wisconsin (new Democratic trifecta starting in January), Texas (Gina Hinojosa in the governor’s chair and Dems controlling the House), and Kansas (vote count ongoing, but Cindy Holscher is ahead in the governor’s race, and Dems have broken the GOP’s supermajority in the House). It’s far from a sure thing, though. The Milwaukee Journal Sentinel’s Sarah Volpenhein reports that in Wisconsin, Democrats might not push for expansion right away. Georgia Dems will have to work with a Republican-controlled Senate, as will Hinojosa and her House allies in Texas. Some politicians are pumped, though—on Monday, Texas state Representative John Bucy III pre-filed House Bills 101 and 102 to tee things up.

A tally you may have missed: Despite many conservatives’ attempts to portray public transit as a socialist plot that real people hate, voters in this election approved a striking 22 out of 27 public transit ballot measures. (If you’re interested in this topic, it’s always a good time to read Liza Featherstone’s classic, insightful piece about why public transit serves as a high-stakes testing ground for competing visions of the role of government in modern society.)

—Heather Souvaine Horn

The Ideas Factory

The Roosevelt Institute has published a useful rundown from Asad Ramzanali of the Vanderbilt Policy Accelerator, Andrea Dehlendorf of Democracy Takes Work, Molly Kinder of the Breakwater Initiative, and Brian McGrail of Encode on what Anthropic’s upcoming IPO “means for the economy.” Several members of the panel insist, unsurprisingly, that there’s an urgent need for government oversight and regulation. “I fear,” McGrail writes, “that going public will only make it harder for Anthropic to choose safe technology over short-term shareholder interests.”

On Thursday at 10 a.m., the Center for Strategic and International Studies will hold an online discussion on “Israel’s Elections and the Future of the Middle East.” Mona Yacoubian will moderate a conversation between former U.S. ambassador Michael Ratney, Paul Salem, and Celine Touboul.

—Heather Souvaine Horn

In Closing

Book of the Week: Department of Fate: The Promise, the Power, and the Collapse of America’s Most Consequential Institution

By Nathaniel Philbrick

THE GIST: “As goes DOJ, so goes the republic.” That’s the longtime MS Now host’s basic argument, in a book that is “both a diagnosis and a prescription” for the Department of Justice. The book traces the institution from its origin in the Reconstruction era—when it was created to fight the Ku Klux Klan—to the present, when Attorney General Todd Blanche insists that he is the personal attorney for the president.

PRAISE: Department of Fate has no blurbs—a power move if ever there was one—but Kirkus was laudatory. “Written with a novelist’s skill for revelatory detail and a historian’s sharp eye for continuities, the book both infuriates and inspires. The moral indignation seething through Maddow’s account culminates in her conclusion, in which she calls on Congress to beef up the DOJ’s Office of the Inspector General and reminds us of the department’s long-forgotten purpose: ‘to fight for everyone in America to have the protections of the U.S. Constitution, including against their own government.’”

CRUISING THE INDEX: This is not just a polemic, it’s also a history covering some of the department’s less widely recognized roles, from Reconstruction roots to union busting later in the Gilded Age, to the rise of J. Edgar Hoover in the early 20th century, to the Civil Rights Movement.

TNR’S QUICK CRITICAL ASSESSMENT: Maddow’s witty and biting lineup of attorney generals reminds us that there is nothing new about a Department of Justice awash with corruption scandals or attorney generals who see their role primarily as protecting the interests of the powerful. But this also strengthens Maddow’s argument that the Trump era represents a departure even from the DOJ’s often sordid history. This is not a good moment for the DOJ.  Maddow presents a compelling case for how to fix it.

—Alex Shephard

Political Trivia Question of the Day  

Who was the last Cabinet official to be impeached by the House? Hint: It was quite recent! (Sign up for The TNR Blue Book to find the answer in tomorrow’s newsletter.)

—Michael Tomasky

Who Will Dems Investigate First?

Big Tech? ICE? Decisions, decisions ...

Presented by CAP
Randy Villegas speaks to a person to his right while walking outside.
California Representative-elect Randy Villegas speaks to the media in Washington, D.C., on November 8.
Aaron Schwartz/Getty Images
California Representative-elect Randy Villegas speaks to the media in Washington, D.C., on November 8.
Presented by CAP

You’re reading The TNR Blue Book. Get daily scoops, strategy, and developments inside the liberal ideas factory delivered right to your inbox. Sign up for free.

Inside Washington

“LAWYER UP.” That was the election night message from Representative Robert Garcia, ranking member of the House Oversight Committee. In January, one of Democrats’ top priorities will be oversight of the Trump administration, corporate America, and Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE). With so many potential targets for subpoenas and hearings, the only question left is: Where will Democrats start?

“The malfeasance list is so large that ranking is a little bit like choosing amongst your children,” said Lisa Gilbert, co-president of Public Citizen, when I asked how she’d like Democrats to prioritize their oversight efforts. She has some ideas, though: “Pick corporate villains but not just corporate villains in a vacuum,” she said. “Those that really help connect Trump corruption to tangible harms regular people are experiencing.” To start, she suggested tech billionaires Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, and Mark Zuckerberg.

Some incoming House Democrats, in town for their new member orientation, shared their priorities on Monday, which often mirrored their districts or experiences. They also pointed to opportunities to tie accountability to other concerns, like immigration and affordability, that drove voters to the polls last Tuesday.

“I was the mayor of a community that was under federal occupation,” said Representative-elect Daniel Biss, who was previously the mayor of Evanston, a suburb just north of Chicago. “I watched my constituents [get] abducted off the streets because of the color of their skin, where their entire community was terrorized and traumatized, and I just feel deeply compelled to hold ICE and the entire DHS process accountable.”

Randy Villegas, who was elected to represent a majority-Latino district in California’s Central Valley, also has his sights set on ICE. “I very much want to visit the detention center within my district, both Mesa Verde in Bakersfield, California, as well as the extension in McFarland,” he said. “Ultimately, I don’t believe any private corporation should be benefiting off the separation of our families. So I’ll definitely make immigration one of my top priorities.” Both of the facilities he mentioned are operated by the GEO Group, a private prison company contracted with ICE.

Adam Hamawy, a physician who was elected to represent New Jersey’s 12th congressional district, pointed to corporate corruption as his main priority. “Health care insurance has always been an issue, but really, it’s all the big mega corporations,” he said.

Many outside experts and advocates also have their eyes on investigating corporate misdeeds and pay-to-play schemes. “We’ve been following the Trump crypto conflicts of interest since he took office,” said Virginia Canter, chief counsel for ethics and anti-corruption at Democracy Defenders Fund. She also pointed to Musk’s contracts with the federal government and the ties between the Starlink system and the war in Ukraine. Musk reportedly ordered the slowdown of a Starlink system that Ukraine relied upon, blindsiding the Ukrainian government. “Should a private individual have the power to use technology in a fashion that could undermine U.S. national security interests?” Canter asked.

Legal scholar Melissa Murray, a professor at NYU Law, wants Congress to closely scrutinize potential ethics breaches in the court system, including the Supreme Court, and to consider specific reforms. “Real attention to recusal rules. Maybe questions about the court’s docket, its use of the shadow docket,” she suggested. After all, anything Democrats do in Congress “with regard to policymaking is going to be challenged, and it’ll ultimately end up in a federal court, probably the Supreme Court,” she said.

Democrats will have no shortage of people and corporations to investigate beginning in January. But it has to be a two-pronged effort, Gilbert said. Democrats will need “to tell the story, both with oversight, substantive investigations, and hearings that hold up and show accountability for these bad actors,” while also coupling those hearings with “substantive policy that lays out an agenda for fixing the systemic corruption we’re seeing,” she said. “It’s really going to be that one-two punch.”

—Emma Janssen

Outside Washington

As Stephen Miller, Trump’s immigration strategy architect, starts his new job as White House chief of staff, The New York Times published a brutal account of how the Trump administration’s policy of deporting court-protected asylum-seekers to third countries has resulted in “many of them being pushed back to the very countries where the Trump administration itself cannot legally send them,” where they face “torture, sexual abuse or persecution.” The Times’ Megha Rajagopalan, Edward Wong, Ruth Maclean, and Hamed Aleaziz have identified 110 individuals sent back to their origin countries in this way. Human rights groups say that’s “almost certainly an undercount.”

The 31st United Nations climate summit (COP31) is underway in Turkey this week. Like last year, there will be no official U.S. representatives there, but a number of non-federal politicians are attending. Among those politicians are 19 members of Congress, all of them Democrats, with Representative Sean Casten of Illinois so far leading the charge in terms of talking to the press. As the summit opened, the U.N.’s World Meteorological Organization issued a dire global climate update. University College London professor emeritus Bill McGuire tells The Guardian that “the latest research suggests we will cross the 1.5C limit permanently in 2028, and with the planet now heating at an extraordinary rate of 0.4C a decade, we can expect to smash through 2C in the late 2030s.” The takeaway? Democrats who kept quiet about climate change on the campaign trail may want to add it back to the to-do list—particularly given climate change’s well-documented contributions to the affordability crisis.

—Heather Souvaine Horn

The Ideas Factory

The Open Markets Institute published a troubling new report on how top tech companies (you know the ones) “could leverage their control over cloud computing, foundation models, operating systems, browsers, online search, and digital platforms to dominate AI agents, exclude competitors, and extend their power even further across the economy and society.” One of the report’s top recommendations: U.S. and European policymakers should “require interoperability and data portability,” authors Max von Thun, Courtney C. Radsch, George Colville, and Dora Wierzbicka write, to reduce top companies’ ability to suppress competition.

In case you missed it: At the Center for American Progress, Damian Murphy recently penned a guide for how Democrats can end the war on Iran. His top step is to “cut off funding for the war effort in an appropriations package.” A war powers resolution would be good, too, he writes, but “the single most powerful tool Congress has at its disposal to bring about an end to the war is the power of the purse.”

The Natural Resources Defense Council is among numerous groups continuing to oppose the permitting reform bill titled the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026—even with its recent modifications. “We support the elements of the legislation that help accelerate needed transmission, clean energy deployment, and grid modernization; but the current package goes too far in weakening essential environmental safeguards and public participation requirements,” said Manish Bapna, NRDC president, in a statement published on the organization’s website on Sunday. In his newsletter called The Crucial Years, environmentalist Bill McKibben has a user-friendly rundown of the reasons why environmental and some accountability advocates are opposing this bill.

—Heather Souvaine Horn

In Closing

Political Trivia Question of the Day  

Who was the first defense secretary, nominated by Harry Truman in 1947 after the modern Defense Department was created? (Sign up for The TNR Blue Book to find the answer in tomorrow’s newsletter.)

—Michael Tomasky