You are using an outdated browser.
Please upgrade your browser
and improve your visit to our site.
Skip Navigation

This is the stuff of print editors’ nightmares.

Last summer, the world of professional bridge was upended by a cheating scandal involving some of the highest-ranking players in the game. This is prime magazine feature article territory. Scandal rocks obscure subculture? Sold! And so, low and behold, several months later, we have this:

Yes, that’s right, the bridge scandal story appears in the March issue of Vanity Fair and the March 7 issue of The New YorkerRolling Stone also got in on the action with its own feature, published today.

Feature articles generally take a long time to report, write, edit, fact-check, and go through production for print. Writers and editors often live in fear of someone else scooping them on a story. 

(Pamela Colloff famously recalled a close call she had while looking into the story of Cameron Todd Willingham. “A very nice man from New York was just here,” Willingham’s stepmother told her. “He’s a reporter too. Maybe you know him? His name is David Grann.”)

But there hasn’t been a pileup like this since 2012, when GQ and Esquire published competing accounts of the Zanesville zoo massacre.

Personally, I plan to read all three versions—a little good karma as I think about the features I’m editing—and I suggest you do the same.