You are using an outdated browser.
Please upgrade your browser
and improve your visit to our site.
Skip Navigation

Sparks Flying In South Carolina

Folks, if you're not watching the South Carolina debate, you really should tune in.

I can't take notes quickly enough to keep up, so here's a paraphrased run-down of what's just transpired on the second question...

OBAMA: Hillary Clinton has been distorting my record -- including what I said about Ronald Reagan in an editorial board meeting, suggesting I praised Republican ideas.

CLINTON:  I'm just going by what you've said.  You said the Republicans were the party of ideas and that you admired them for it.

OBAMA:  I never said that.

CLINTON:  Yes you did.

OBAMA:  No, I didn't.  I said he was a transformative figure.  I've always disagreed with his ideas.  I saw the impact they had on communities during the 1980s, because I was organizing on the streets of Chicago back then -- while you were a corporate laywer sitting on the board of Wal-Mart.

CLINTON:  Let's get back to the quote. 

And then, later, Clinton denied making a certain accusation about Obama, saying this:

CLINTON:  I didn't say that.

OBAMA:  OK, your husband did.

CLINTON:  Well, he's not here now -- I am.

OBAMA.  I know, but sometimes it's hard to know who I am running against.

At that point, Clinton said something about Obama working for a slum lord -- frankly, I couldn't hear because my wife and I were too busy gasping at the back and forth.  Then Edwards spoke, suggesting that this wasn't helpilng to get people jobs and make sure kids have health insurance -- and that, by the way, he was the first candidate with comprehensive plans for universal health care, energy, and such.  (All true claims, as best as I can tell.)

I'll revisit this all when I have a real transcript -- and maybe video.  In the meantime, I think it's safe to say that Obama has decided he's going to hit back at Clinton -- and the Clintons -- in this debate.  And it's become something of a free-for-all.

Note: notwithstanding this exchange, it's actually been quite substantive.  Prior to this, there was a very meaty debate about trade. 

Update: Marc Ambinder has some of the precise excerpts.

Update 2: Ben Smith has a longer transcript

--Jonathan Cohn