You are using an outdated browser.
Please upgrade your browser
and improve your visit to our site.
Skip Navigation

Labor Pains

The Absurd Comedy of the Dems' Labor Suck Up

Last night's AFL-CIO Democratic Presidential Candidate Debate in Chicago made for electrifying television. Famed "Countdown" host Keith Olbermann clearly relished his role. Hillary Clinton's blouse was modest, but I still saw a bit more neck than I thought appropriate. For those of you who missed it, it all went down something like this:

KEITH OLBERMANN: Welcome! Yay unions!

CHRIS DODD: Yay unions! I love mine workers. Safe bridges and highways rule. A Dem will win in 2008.

HILLARY CLINTON: Yay unions! Go Bears! My dad would love that his kid is "playing" at Soldier's Field. I love mine workers. Infrastructure, homeland security, Katrina, levees in New Orleans, bridges in Minnesota, 9/11!!!!

BARACK OBAMA: Welcome to Chi-town. Go Bears! Yay unions! We never should have gone to Iraq. We should go to Pakistan!

JOE BIDEN: Put America back to work. Security! Safety! 9/11 Commission Report! Plus, Hillary's subways suck.

JOHN EDWARDS: Yay unions! I love Minnesota. I love Utah mine workers. But mostly I love...Unions! Oh, and lobbyists are evil!

DENNIS KUCINICH: I believe we should create a Marxist utopia based on principles of shared goals and mutual respect, collective bargaining, and the right to strike. Workers of the world unite!!!

OBAMA: Soldier Field rules!

BILL RICHARDSON: Yay unions! (Please like me ... .)

OLBERMANN: OK, moving on. China: friend or foe?

CLINTON: We import things from China, people. Ewww. Think of your pets! If those Commies cared about health and safety the way you do, Fluffy would still be alive.

EDWARDS: Toys!!! We import toys from China. Think of the children. No one has even mentioned human rights.

KUCINICH: If you dig a hole long enough, you can get to China.

OLBERMANN: Next question: What if you pull out of Iraq and, heh heh, Al Qaeda takes over anyway?

OBAMA: I did not vote for this war!

BIDEN: I'm the only one with a plan.

CLINTON: I have a three-point plan.

EDWARDS: I would plan and prepare for all possible outcomes.

KUCINICH: I'm the only one who voted "no" on the war and "no" on more spending in Iraq, so step off Obama.

DODD: Ummm, didn't Obama say we should invade Pakistan? Let's bring that back up. Don't commit to things you can't deliver, Barack.

OBAMA: I thought we were friends, Chris. But you voted to get us into Iraq, and now I'm being ridiculed for wanting to take the fight to the right battlefield?! Remember, I did not vote for this war. I said no to the Iraq war. Bad idea, that's what I said.

CLINTON: Hey Obama, ixnay on the Akistanpay. Bin Adenlay might be isteninglay.

DODD: You're crazy Obama!

OBAMA: At least I didn't vote for the war!

OLBERMANN: Shut it, all of you. Let's take some questions from the audience.

SAGO MINE WIDOW: How will you improve safety in mines?

BIDEN: We may not love Musharraf but we need him right now.

HOSPITAL WORKER: I want to start a union at my job.

KUCINICH: Omigod, I know so many people who can help you with that. Yay unions! It's gonna be so awesome. I am super psyched for you!

IRAQ VET: I came back from Iraq to find I'd lost my Maytag job to Mexico. What will you do to protect my job and health care?

RICHARDSON: Health care and pensions for ALL Maytag workers! And you get a super cool red and silver "Hero's Health Card."

UNION MEMBER: My company filed for bankruptcy and I lost my pension. What's wrong with America?

EDWARDS: You are a perfect example of what's wrong with America! Let's treat CEOs like regular people! Universal health care! Yay unions! I'm the union man! I walked 200 freakin' picket lines! Who was with you, unions? Me! I was! I am the union guy, people. Yay unions!

CLINTON: I love audience members, and I love audience members who ask questions. Is that a new Teamster tee? Fabulous. You all look great. What are you doing after? By the way, I'll sign the Employee Free Choice Act.

IMMIGRANT: I just became an American citizen. What are you going to do about undocumented workers in the U.S.?

OBAMA: It's your first vote! That's so cool. Oh dude, totally make me your first vote. That would be sweeeet. We are a nation of laws and a nation of immigrants. By the way, I love unions! Illinois labor is all me. Yay unions!

NURSE: The health care system in this country is a total goddam disgrace.

BIDEN: If there are angels in Heaven, they're nurses. But enough about health care. Unions rule! I have walked my share of picket lines!! Nobody has a better record of walking than me. I did picket lines the whole time I was in the Senate. Picketing is just, like, a no-brainer, man. And I did it first.

KUCINICH: Universal health care for everyone!!

EDWARDS: 200 pickets, people! 200!! I picketed on Saturday. Hell, I picketed on Sunday. Everyone here knows it. Everyone knows that I am the labor guy here. No scab can break the line! That's what I always say. No scab breaks the line! That's the America I believe in. 200 pickets!!

OLBERMANN: Aren't you from a right-to-work state, Senator Edwards?

EDWARDS: Er, I guess. The point is: If the union was a person, I would kneel down and wash its toes with my tongue! And I know all the words to "Coal Miner's Daughter."

BIDEN: I washed Union's toes with my tongue first.

UNION MEMBER: How will you be energy-efficient?

DODD: I'd like to talk about health care.

TEACHER: How do you feel about No Child Left Behind?

CLINTON: A child is not a walking test. A child is a biological entity that requires a village and maybe some private tutors and great extracurriculars.

OLBERMANN: Moving on...You've waited all night, ladies and gentlemen, and I am now happy to present the Lightening Round! Double points for all correct answers. Also, the judges are telling me that it is still mathematically possible for Senator Dodd to win--if he answers all the questions right and everyone else gets at least one wrong. Ready?!

RICHARDSON: My veep would not be Cheney. It would be someone up here on stage....And his first name begins with a B and his last name starts with Obama.

CLINTON: I may take money from lobbyists, but in truth I hate them. I hate lobbyists, and I love unions! People at the union call me "sister."

OBAMA: I fight for you, not the check writers! Unless you are the check writers. I fight for the people who give me checks and who are also not lobbyists....And Barry Bonds may or may not be welcome at the White House.

BIDEN: I am not racist toward Republicans.

DODD: In a parliamentary system, Bush would so be gone by now.

EDWARDS: Lobbyists bad. Lawyers good. Unions the best. 200 pickets!

KUCINICH: I am officially changing my name to "Sea Biscuit."

OLBERMANN: That's a wrap. Let's hear from the judges...

CHRIS MATHEWS: Hillary Clinton, you've just won a brand-new Maytag washing machine direct from the beautiful Yucatan Peninsula.

By Sacha Zimmerman