You are using an outdated browser.
Please upgrade your browser
and improve your visit to our site.
Skip Navigation

Military Spending as Fiscal Stimulus?

Martin Feldstein -- Harvard economist, McCain advisor, and member of Obama's Recovery Advisory Board -- wants more resources devoted to defense spending:

The focus on domestic economic policies in the 1930s and the desire to remain militarily neutral delayed the major military buildup that eventually achieved the economic recovery. The administration’s current budget point to a one‐fifth reduction in the share of GDP devoted to defense over the next decade. In light of the increased range of adversaries and threats that the nation now faces, there are likely to be substantial national security benefits to increasing the share of GDP devoted to defense and other aspects of international security.

But Feldstein's notion that military spending "eventually achieved the economic recovery" is debatable.

Fellow conservative Harvard economist Robert Barro has argued that increased military spending during WWII actually depressed other parts of the economy.

Also from the right, Robert Higgs has done good work showing that military spending wasn't the primary source of the recovery and that GDP growth during WWII has been "greatly exaggerated."

And from the left, Larry Summers and Brad Delong argued back in 1988 that "five-sixths of the decline in output relative to the trend that occurred during the Depression had been made up before 1942."

It's also worth looking at the progression of defense spending as a percentage of the budget after WWII:

Although defense spending has seen a relative decline over the last 60 years, the U.S. is still the #1 military power in the world. It's also hard to see an obvious correlation between military spending and GDP. And, pace Feldstein, the problems associated with the current War on Terror seem to have resulted more from lousy decision-making and oversight than a shortage of funds. So it's really hard to see why a larger portion of the already strapped budget should be devoted to the military.