You are using an outdated browser.
Please upgrade your browser
and improve your visit to our site.
Skip Navigation

"Saving The Soul Of America"

In his victory speech Mitt Romney said, "Our campaign is about more than replacing a President; it is about saving the soul of America." It's a line he's used before in speeches and at least one ad, and it's not a good idea. Here's why.

1.) America's soul doesn't need saving. I'm a Democrat, but I'd think that even if I were a Republican. In 2004 I took John Kerry to task for adopting as his slogan, "Let America be America again." Partly I objected because the line was taken from a crappy propagandistic poem by the great American poet Langston Hughes during his unfortunate Stalinist period. But partly I objected because I found the hubris and grandiosity distasteful. America is America even when its president is someone I don't like. Even if I thought America needed a new president I wouldn't think its very soul in peril if we didn't get one. Its soul is doing just fine, thank you very much.

2.) The Billy Sunday-style rhetoric ill suits Romney, a politician whose soul is perpetually up for grabs. Even if I thought America needed a preacher-in-chief, I wouldn't hire a shape-shifter like Romney for the job.

3.) The language of evangelism inadvertently evokes Romney's Mormonism. This is a guy who actually spent some of his life trying to convert people (and not just any people; French people!) to Mormonism. What do missionaries do? They save souls. I think a Mormon has every right to run for president. But just as I wouldn't have advised John Kennedy in the 1960 race to employ sacramental metaphors, I don't think it's wise for Romney to employ metaphors that risk making people think he wants the Angel Moroni to come a-knockin' on their door.

You're welcome to seek my vote, governor. But leave my soul the hell alone.