As the Jeffrey Epstein scandal has worsened, President Trump’s story has been that it’s all Democratic “hoax,” and that his signature on that lewd drawing in Epstein’s birthday book is a “forgery.” But at a congressional hearing Wednesday, FBI director Kash Patel faltered under intense questioning from Democrats. Patel filibustered when asked whether Trump’s name is in the Epstein files. He seemed to accidentally reveal that he does know how many times Trump’s name appears. And he agreed to investigate whether Trump’s birthday note to Epstein is indeed forged, which seems ill-advised. Patel badly undermined Trump’s whole stance. So how much longer can Trumpworld keep the lid on this? We talked to Nicole Hemmer, a historian who has written excellent books about the right and its media apparatus. She explains the schism Epstein has opened inside MAGA, how Patel exposed Trump’s position as untenable, and how it all fits into the last half-century of right wing deceptions and conspiracy theories. Listen to this episode here.
PODCAST
Trump’s Epstein Spin Implodes as Kash Patel Buckles Under Dem Grilling
As the FBI director falters under a tough grilling from Democrats, undermining Trump’s defense on the Jeffrey Epstein scandal, an expert on the right explains why this fiasco is so awful for Trump and MAGA.

Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images
FBI Director Kash Patel in Washington, DC on September 16, 2025.