Sotomayor’s Harsh Dissent on Trump Arrests Offers a Terrifying Warning | The New Republic
PODCAST

Sotomayor’s Harsh Dissent on Trump Arrests Offers a Terrifying Warning

As the Supreme Court begins ruling on Trump’s deportations, a legal expert unravels the complexities of all these cases and explains how Sonia Sotomayor laid bare the truly alarming stakes we currently face.

Pablo Cuadra/Getty Images
Supreme Court Justice Sonia Sotomayor in Madrid, on March 4, 2024

The fate of dozens of Venezuelans deported by the Trump administration to a maximum security prison in El Salvador remains in doubt. So does the fate of Kilmar Abrego Garcia, who administration officials admit was removed in error even as they refuse to return him to the United States. The Supreme Court just issued rulings on these cases, putting a hold on a lower court’s order to reverse Abrego Garcia’s removal, and allowing the deportations of Venezuelans to resume for now. In that second one, Sonia Sotomayor issued a powerful dissent, and buried in it is an alarming warning. We talked to American Immigration Council senior fellow Aaron Reichlin-Melnick, who expertly demystifies these rulings for us and explains how Sotomayor laid bare the alarming stakes we face at this fraught moment. Listen to this episode here. A transcript is here.