Kash Patel’s FBI Flails as Person of Interest in Guthrie Case Released
The FBI doesn’t appear to be any closer to finding out who kidnapped Nancy Guthrie.

FBI Director Kash Patel has once again prematurely announced a major update in a criminal investigation, only to have to walk it back hours later.
Police detained and questioned a person of interest on Tuesday night regarding the kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie, mother of Today show host Savannah Guthrie, who was taken from her Arizona home over a week ago. New security camera footage released by the FBI shows masked men on the front porch of Guthrie’s home the night she disappeared, but she still remains missing.
On Tuesday, Patel went on Fox News with Sean Hannity and touted the FBI’s “brilliant” relationship with private-sector companies that allowed them to make “substantial progress in these last 36 [to] 48 hours.
“And I do believe we are looking at people who, as we say, are persons of interest,” he continued. At least one of those “persons” appears to be a completely innocent man.
The Pima County Sheriff’s Department, supported by Patel’s FBI, detained a man who identified himself as Carlos at a traffic stop in Tucson on Tuesday. He was released the same day, and later spoke to reporters outside his home, profusely proclaiming his innocence.
“[It was] terrifying. Something I didn’t do … I felt like I was being kidnapped bro. They didn’t tell me anything at the beginning,” Carlos said, visibly shaken as his voice wavered. He said he was followed, detained at random, and questioned about his “whereabouts” and personal information by police. He was “held against his will” and says he wasn’t read his Miranda rights until two hours into his detainment.
🚨 NEW: The man detained and now RELEASED in the Nancy Guthrie investigation speaks out:
— TV News Now (@TVNewsNow) February 11, 2026
He says he had ZERO idea what was going on.
“I’m just a delivery driver in Tucson. That’s it.”
pic.twitter.com/TBKNTldLpi
“Are you ever up in Tucson?” a reporter asked Carlos.
“I work in Tucson … GLS, deliver packages,” he replied.
“Do you think you might have delivered a package to Nancy Guthrie’s house?”
“I don’t know, might’ve been a possibility.”
Carlos, answering questions in both English and Spanish, later stated that he had no idea who Guthrie even was, and that he didn’t watch the Today show.
“I hope they get the suspect. Because I’m not it. And they better do their job and find the suspect that did it so they can clear my name. And I’m done. Look at what I’m putting my family through,” he continued. “Not just them, but my parents in Tucson.”
This is Carlos who says he was pulled over by police and was accused of kidnapping #NancyGuthrie.
— Andres Gutierrez (@AFGutierrez) February 11, 2026
They have released him.
We just spoke with him outside his house in Rio Rico Arizona
@CBSNews pic.twitter.com/BmsR2q5jBl
Detaining and interrogating a random person before throwing them out the door has become a pattern for the Patel FBI in high-profile investigations.
Last September, Patel came under fire from the left and right for his premature social media post the day Charlie Kirk was shot, declaring that “the subject for the horrific shooting” was in custody—a claim almost immediately contradicted by local officials. Patel later backtracked, and the manhunt ensued for another 27-plus hours before the suspect, Tyler Robinson, was turned in by a family member.
And in December, the FBI director wrote a long post boasting about the bureau’s efforts to detain another person of interest in the Brown University shooting that killed two and wounded nine. Blunders like these are only magnified under a bureau now left to the whims of Patel, who insists on force and bravado that does not match his success rate.








